How to cook a steak at home: thickness, heat and resting
A steak is one of the few things you can cook at home that a restaurant cannot do better, provided two things are right before the meat touches heat: the thickness, and how dry the surface is. Everything else is timing.
Ask for the thickness first, the cut second
Most disappointment with home steak comes from a piece that is too thin. A 1 cm steak is grey inside before the outside has browned, and browning is where the flavour is. You want 2.5 to 3 cm, roughly a finger's width, and even across the whole piece. Uneven thickness means one end overcooks while the thick end is still raw.
Allow 300 to 350 g per person for rump or sirloin. A T-bone at 500 to 600 g is one hungry person, or two people if there are sides. Fillet fills less because it carries no fat, so 200 to 250 g each is enough.
Which cuts are worth the money
- Rump. Best value for a home pan. Strong beef flavour, a cap of fat that bastes the meat as it cooks, and it stays forgiving if you go slightly past medium.
- Sirloin. Tender, a little milder, and the safest choice if you do not know how your guests like it.
- T-bone. Two textures in one piece, and the bone keeps the middle juicy.
- Fillet. The tenderest and least flavoursome, because there is almost no fat. It has no margin for overcooking and needs a fast sear and a butter baste at the end.
What to say at the counter
Give the butcher the thickness and the weight, not the count. "Two rump steaks, 3 cm thick, about 300 g each" gets you a better result than "two steaks". Ask for them cut from the thick end of the rump rather than the thin tail, and for the fat cap to be left on. Ask for the silver skin on the outside trimmed, because that membrane contracts and curls the steak in the pan.
If you are buying for the same evening, say so. All our beef is cut to order at City Market Stall 56 and has never been frozen, so it is firmer than meat that has sat for a day. That is not a fault, but it will cook faster than a supermarket steak of the same thickness.
Dry it, then salt it
Pat the steak completely dry with kitchen paper. A wet surface has to boil off its water before it can brown, and that steam is the difference between grey meat and a crust. If you have an hour, leave it uncovered on a rack in the fridge and the cold dry air will pull the moisture off.
Salt generously, more than feels reasonable, on both sides. Either salt it 45 minutes ahead so the salt draws moisture out, dissolves and is drawn back in, or salt it immediately before it hits the pan. Between 5 and 30 minutes is the one bad window, because the surface is wet again and will steam.
The pan and the heat
Use the heaviest pan you own, cast iron or thick stainless, and get it properly hot before the meat goes in. Use an oil that can take the heat, not butter, which burns at steak temperatures. Butter comes in the last minute with a crushed garlic clove and a sprig of rosemary, spooned over as it foams.
Do not crowd the pan. Two steaks in a 28 cm pan is the limit. Three will drop the temperature and you will end up steaming them instead of browning them. Cook in batches and rest them together.
Timing by thickness
- 2.5 cm, medium rare: about 2 minutes on the first side, 2 on the second, then 1 minute on the fat edge.
- 3 cm, medium rare: 2.5 minutes a side, then 2 to 3 minutes in a 200C oven.
- 3.5 cm or thicker: sear 3 minutes a side, then finish in the oven 5 to 7 minutes. A piece this thick will not cook through on the hob alone without burning outside.
With a thermometer, pull the steak at 52 to 54C for rare, 57 to 60C for medium rare, 63C for medium. It will climb another 3 to 5 degrees while resting, so pull it early rather than late.
Rest it, then cut it the right way
Rest on a warm plate for 5 minutes for a 2.5 cm piece, up to 8 minutes for anything thicker. Cover loosely, not wrapped tight in foil, or the crust will go soft. Cut across the grain, which on rump and sirloin means slicing perpendicular to the lines running through the meat. Slicing along them makes even a good steak feel stringy.
The common faults, in the order they happen
Steak bought too thin. Surface not dried. Pan not hot enough. Too many pieces at once. Cut open too early to check. Any one of those costs you more than a cheaper cut ever would.
We cut to order at City Market Stall 56, so you can ask for an exact thickness and any weight from 0.5 kg. The meat is halal and never frozen, and we deliver same day across Nairobi. Pay by M-Pesa on till 9700565.
Cut to order, never frozen, delivered across Nairobi the same day if you order by 6:30 PM.
See what we have today →